A fair look at the research behind the Big Five, HEXACO, Hogan, MBTI, DiSC, CliftonStrengths, and the Enneagram, and how to judge any test yourself.
Short answer
Tests built on the Big Five, also called the Five Factor Model, have the deepest research base in personality psychology. Well-built Big Five measures such as the public-domain IPIP-NEO score traits on a continuous scale and produce consistent results over time. HEXACO, a six-factor cousin of the Big Five, is also well researched, and Hogan's inventories are Big Five based and built for workplace use. Type and style tools such as MBTI and DiSC are popular and easy to remember, and they work best as conversation starters rather than precise measures.
Written by Christin Camacho, Founder and CEO of Big 5 at Work. Last updated October 2026.
Key takeaways
How to judge a test
You can judge any test by four things. Start with reliability: do people get similar results a few weeks later? Then look at construct validity, which asks whether the scores line up with other established measures of the same traits. Check whether the test is described in peer-reviewed journals or only in the publisher's own materials. Finally, look for clear limits, meaning the publisher tells you what the test should not be used for.
Comparison
A percentile for each of the five traits and the facets behind them, from a public-domain instrument published in peer-reviewed research (Johnson, 2014). The Comprehensive Assessment from Big 5 at Work is adapted from it. Best for team development that needs precision and a view of how people respond to pressure; percentiles take a minute to explain.
A six-factor inventory by Kibeom Lee and Michael Ashton that adds Honesty-Humility to the Big Five dimensions, with a strong peer-reviewed base. It's used more in research than in team workshops.
Big Five based, with added scales for derailers and values and a large body of workplace research. Best for leadership development; only certified practitioners can buy and administer it.
One of 16 types from four preference pairs. The publisher reports reliability and validity evidence, and independent critics have questioned how consistently people get the same type. Best for shared vocabulary; the publisher says not to use it for selection.
A style and position on a four-style circle. Most published validity research on Everything DiSC comes from its publisher. Best for quick, friendly team language, with less detail than trait scores.
34 talent themes in ranked order, supported by Gallup's technical reports. Best for strengths and engagement work; it measures talents rather than personality traits.
A type from 1 to 9 organized around motivation. Its research base is smaller, and different tests can give different results.
Why the Big Five
The Big Five came from studying how people describe each other across many languages, then testing which descriptions cluster together. Five broad traits keep appearing: Openness, Conscientiousness, Extraversion, Agreeableness, and Neuroticism. Because the model was found in data rather than designed from a theory, researchers around the world have been able to test it, criticize it, and refine it for decades.
Two features make it useful at work. Traits are measured on a spectrum, so you see degree and not just direction. And it includes Neuroticism, which describes how quickly someone notices risk and responds to pressure: people who score higher often spot problems early, and people who score lower often stay steady when plans change, and a team needs both. Traits are stable but still change over a lifetime, and research shows they relate to life outcomes in real but modest ways.
Big 5 at Work
The Comprehensive Assessment is adapted from the IPIP-NEO, a public-domain measure of the Five Factor Model developed by researchers and published in peer-reviewed journals. It reports your five traits and the facets behind them in plain workplace language, and the AI-powered Virtual Coach helps you interpret your results. It costs $5 per person for your first 20 people and $12 per person after that, and it is designed for development only, not for hiring or performance reviews.
FAQ
Well-built Big Five measures have the strongest research base, and HEXACO and Hogan are also well researched.
A public-domain measure of the Big Five and its facets, described by its developer in the Journal of Research in Personality. The Comprehensive Assessment from Big 5 at Work is adapted from it.
Its publisher reports evidence for reliability and validity, while independent critics question how consistently people get the same type on retest.
Some tests are designed and validated for selection. Big 5 at Work is not; it is for team development only.
Sources