What MBTI does well for teams, what critics say about its reliability, and when a Big Five assessment gives your team more to work with.
Short answer
For a first conversation about differences, yes. MBTI gives teams a familiar, positive vocabulary, and many people remember their type for years. Where it is less reliable is precision: because it sorts people into one of two categories on each scale, people near the middle can get a different type when they retake it. If your team needs to understand specific friction points or how people respond to pressure, a Big Five assessment, which reports each trait on a spectrum, gives you more to work with.
Written by Christin Camacho, Founder and CEO of Big 5 at Work. Last updated November 2026.
Key takeaways
Strengths
MBTI's biggest strength is shared language. Saying “I'm an introvert, so I'd like the agenda ahead of time” is easy and non-threatening, and the 16 types are framed as preferences, which helps teams talk about differences without judging them. It also has a large network of certified practitioners, so you can find a facilitator in most regions.
The research
Reliability means getting similar results when you take a test again. The Myers-Briggs Company describes a body of evidence for MBTI's reliability and validity. Critics, including leadership psychologist Ronald Riggio, point to the scoring method: when results are forced into two categories, changing a couple of answers can move someone from “E” to “I,” and many people get a different type when they retake it.
That doesn't make the underlying preferences random. It means a type label hides how strong each preference is, so two people with the same type can differ a lot, and two people with different types can be almost identical.
Comparison
MBTI gives you one of 16 types. A Big Five assessment gives you a percentile for each of five traits, and the Comprehensive Assessment from Big 5 at Work adds the facets behind them, so you see how strongly each trait shows up.
MBTI doesn't measure it. The Big Five includes Neuroticism, which describes how quickly someone notices risk and responds to pressure.
An MBTI type can change for people near a midpoint. Big Five scores shift a little over time, with no cutoff to cross.
MBTI is given to others by an MBTI Certified Practitioner or an eligible professional. Anyone can take the Big 5 at Work assessment online, and Big 5 at Work Consultants complete free training.
MBTIonline is $59.95 for an individual. The Comprehensive Assessment is $5 per person for your first 20 people, then $12.
Researchers McCrae and Costa have shown that MBTI's scales line up with four of the Big Five traits. The Big Five keeps each scale whole instead of cutting it in half, and adds Neuroticism.
Choosing
Stay with MBTI if your team already knows their types and uses the vocabulary, if you want a light first session, or if you have an MBTI practitioner you trust. A Big Five assessment gives you more when the same people keep running into the same friction and you want to see why, when people react very differently to deadlines and pressure, or when you want results you can compare person to person rather than type to type.
You don't have to start over. Many teams keep their MBTI vocabulary and add a Big Five view for the questions MBTI didn't answer.
Big 5 at Work
The Comprehensive Assessment, adapted from the IPIP-NEO, a public-domain Big Five measure, scores your five traits and the facets behind them, and the AI-powered Virtual Coach helps you interpret your results in the context of your real job. A Team Dashboard ($50 per team) shows everyone's mix in one place for teammates who complete the Comprehensive Assessment. If you'd like a facilitator, a 2 Hour Session is $2,500 and a Half-Day Workshop is $4,500 for groups under 20, and both are optional.
FAQ
If you are near the middle on a scale, a few different answers can move you across the cutoff. Your preference probably didn't change much; the label did.
No. It is based on Jung's theory of psychological type and has published research behind it. Critics question its precision and its two-category scoring, not whether the preferences exist.
For precision and research base, most personality researchers prefer the Big Five. For a quick, familiar vocabulary, MBTI works well, and many teams use both.
Not these tools. MBTI's publisher says it should not be used for hiring or selection, and Big 5 at Work is for development only.
Sources