From Our Founder: control tower
October 11, 2026

Why You Need Neurotic People on Your Team

In short

I named my book after the trait nobody brags about. Here's why I think personality diversity belongs in the diversity conversation, and how it shows up in results.

Of all the words in the personality vocabulary, "neurotic" might have the worst reputation. Call someone open-minded or conscientious and they'll likely take it as a compliment, but call someone neurotic and you've just insulted them. It's the trait nobody lists as a strength in a job interview, which is exactly why I named my book after it.

The book makes the case, and so does this post, that teams do their best work when they include people who don't all see the world the same way, and that no trait is better than another. Neuroticism is simply the clearest example of a trait whose value gets overlooked, often by the very people who benefit from it most.

The Problem With Rose-Colored Glasses

I sit toward the lower end of Neuroticism myself. I'm calm by nature, generally optimistic, and rarely kept up at night by worry, and for most of my career that felt like an unambiguous asset. I tend to see a new idea through rose-colored glasses, picturing everything it could become before I picture what could get in its way. That optimism is a big part of what gets new work off the ground, and it's also exactly why I've learned to seek out colleagues who see the same idea through a different lens.

What took me longer to appreciate was how much the people on my teams who sat toward the higher end were adding. They noticed things I didn't, reacted to things I let pass, and pushed when I was content to wait. Over time I realized that my own calm about a plan was telling me about me, not about the plan. And once I saw that, I stopped treating their concerns as something to manage and started treating them as information I couldn't get anywhere else.

Why You Want a "Negative Nelly" on Your Team

Most people assume the value of Neuroticism begins and ends with spotting risk, and that's part of it: people toward the higher end often sense trouble before there's evidence of it, like a control tower tracking a collision the rest of us aren't watching for. But the trait brings more than that. The colleague who gets angry when a competitor wins the deal is often the one who refuses to let the loss slide, and that frustration turns into a faster response. The one who isn't swept up in the excitement of a new initiative is thinking carefully while everyone else is cheering. And the one who feels pressure most acutely is usually the first to notice when a pace has become unsustainable, well before the rest of the team starts to burn out.

Groupthink Comes in More Than One Flavor

Now of course, the case runs both ways, and it applies to every trait. A team made up entirely of people toward the higher end of Neuroticism would see every risk and find it hard to commit to anything, while a team that leans toward the higher end of Openness may change direction faster than anyone can finish the last idea, and a team high in Conscientiousness may keep perfecting a plan the market has already moved past. A team high in Agreeableness may have trouble saying no to its manager or to colleagues in other departments, until the work piles up and people feel overwhelmed or burned out without ever having said a word, which is why its manager has to notice the pattern and ask.

Each of these teams is simply missing the people whose defaults would balance its own. The most effective teams have a mix of patterns that check each other, so the company can move fast without moving recklessly, and that combination is a real competitive advantage.

The Diversity That Shows Up in Your Results

Most organizations already talk about diversity of background and experience, and for good reason. Personality diversity belongs in that conversation, too. Two people with nearly identical résumés can approach the same decision in completely different ways, because one instinctively looks for what could go right and the other for what could go wrong. You need both instincts in the room, and unlike many things about a team, this one is something you can see and plan for.

But having a mix of personalities only pays off if every one of them gets heard. That means building a culture where all perspectives are welcome, and giving people a real channel to raise ideas and concerns in a way the team can act on, whether that's the cautious voice in a planning meeting or the restless one pitching something new. Companies that get this right can move quickly because the risks have already been surfaced, take calculated bets instead of blind ones, and come up with the kind of ideas that keep them competitive and win new business. Personality diversity shows up in the results.

Good Intentions Fade. Structure Lasts.

There's a reason teams drift toward sameness: a mix of personalities creates more friction than a room full of people who think alike. The person scanning for risk and the person ready to commit will, at some point, frustrate each other. That friction is the price of better decisions, but only if the team has a way to make it productive.

That's where "Scaffolding" comes in: the structures a leader puts in place so people with different defaults can do their best work together. Something as simple as asking the people most likely to spot a risk what could go wrong, before the decision is made rather than after, turns a concern that might sound like resistance into insight the team asked for. It's a practice I now use deliberately, and it's the subject of the next post in this series, How Great Managers Turn Insight Into Habit.

If you're curious where you and your team land, start with the free test. It takes about 10 minutes, and you'll see your five trait scores the moment you finish.

Christin Camacho is the founder and CEO of Big 5 at Work and the author of Why You Need Neurotic People on Your Team.

Big 5 at Work logo

Schedule a team-building workshop
with a lasting impact