In short
A felt read is information worth testing. Ask for a Hunch Note: what the person noticed, what it might mean, and which fact would confirm or rule it out.
Ana had sat through all three vendor demos, and on Thursday morning the comparison sheet put Northgate first by eleven points. When Tom asked for a final yes, she paused and said she couldn't point to a line on the sheet, but she had left Tuesday's call uneasy. Tom had built that sheet over two weeks, so he asked the one question that made sense to him: which number would she change? Both of them were doing their jobs well, and the meeting that followed is one most teams have had.
Key takeaways
- Emotionality is the Openness facet that describes how much you notice your own feelings and treat them as useful information.
- A gut read in a decision meeting usually arrives without evidence attached, so it gets overruled or it quietly stalls the decision.
- A Hunch Note turns that read into three checkable parts, so the team can test it instead of arguing about it.
- Both ends of the facet add something: early notice from one, a steady focus on facts from the other.
What is Emotionality at work?
Emotionality is the Openness facet that describes how attuned you are to your own inner states, and how much you treat them as information worth paying attention to. It doesn't mean being emotional in the everyday sense, and it has nothing to do with being easily upset. In Why You Need Neurotic People on Your Team, Christin Camacho gives it two plain-language ends: "Tuned in to feelings" and "Keeps feelings in the background."
People toward the first end tend to pick up on discomfort in a meeting before others register it. People toward the second end tend to process a situation analytically and stay focused on the facts in front of them, which is a real strength when a clear head matters most.
Why does a gut feeling get set aside in decision meetings?
A felt read and a scorecard speak different languages. Ana's unease was real information, but it came without a reason she could name yet, and Tom had no way to weigh it against eleven points of evidence. When that happens, a team usually does one of two things. It overrules the feeling because nobody can defend it, or the feeling wins by veto because nobody wants to sign over a colleague's objection. Neither outcome tests whether the read was right.
What is a Hunch Note?
A Hunch Note is a short written note that turns a felt read into three things a team can check: what the person noticed, what they think it might mean, and which fact would confirm it or rule it out. Writing it usually takes ten minutes, and it often helps the writer find the reason behind the feeling.
When Ana wrote hers, the reason surfaced. On Tuesday's call, the account lead had moved past two questions about support response times, and the demo had run on a newer version than the one in the quote. Her read: support might be thinner than the sales team suggested. Her checks: call two current customers of a similar size, and ask Northgate for its support terms in writing. Tom added both to the sheet, and the decision moved one day.
How does Two Things Are True help here?
The book's Two Things Are True method fits this moment. Ana opened with something true for Tom: "The sheet covers everything we've measured, and it's the fairest way we have to compare three vendors." Then she named the Objective Constraints: "Two of my questions about support went unanswered on Tuesday, and this contract runs for three years." The shared resolution followed: two reference calls before Friday, and a signature if they checked out.
What does each end of Emotionality bring to a team?
No position on this facet is better for work. Colleagues tuned in to feelings act as an early read on a room, a client, or a deal, and their pitfall is a read that stays unspoken because it doesn't come with a reason attached. Colleagues who keep feelings in the background keep decisions grounded and are hard to pull off course, and their pitfall is giving less weight to a signal the numbers don't show yet. The friction between them is a difference in format, and a team can plan around it together.
How can a manager make room for both?
Before any decision that is costly to reverse, ask one standing question: "Is anyone uneasy about this, even without a reason yet?" Anyone who says yes writes a Hunch Note by the end of the day, and the colleague who owns the analysis turns each check into a step with an owner and a date. If you lean toward feelings, try: "I don't have the reason yet, so give me until three o'clock to write down what I noticed." If you lean toward facts, try: "Tell me what you saw, and I'll find a way to test it before we sign."
Frequently asked questions
Is Emotionality the same as being emotional?
No. In the Big Five, Emotionality is an Openness facet about awareness: how closely you notice your own inner states and treat them as information. It has nothing to do with being easily upset.
How is Emotionality different from Anxiety?
Anxiety is a Neuroticism facet, a Five Factor Model term rather than a clinical diagnosis, that describes how readily someone worries about what could go wrong. Emotionality describes how much attention you pay to what you are feeling, whatever that feeling is.
Is it better to be high or low in Emotionality at work?
Neither. People tuned in to feelings often notice a shift before it shows up in the numbers, and people who keep feelings in the background keep a decision anchored to the facts. A team does well with both, and a Hunch Note gives each end a clear job.
Can Emotionality change, or is it fixed?
It is stable, not fixed. Your traits are your default, not your destiny. They're where you start, and where you drift back to under pressure. The strategies you build, like writing a Hunch Note or asking for one, are how you go further.
Related Reading
- Emotionality at work: reading the mood before the metrics move
- Intellect at work: when one colleague wants to explore and another wants to act
- Anxiety at work: give early concerns a Flag Window
From Big 5 at Work. Curious where you land on Openness? Take the free test at big5atwork.com/quiz.